Nie Qian handed her a tissue and asked her to wipe her tears, and listened to her continue: "When I think about it, I feel stupid. I keep making mistakes again and again and have so many illusions. It's true that he is a bastard, but I am also blind. Fortunately, I am completely awake this time."

"Forget it, it's all normal. What can I say? Who hasn't fallen in love with one or two scumbags when they were young? You haven't Listen to what others say, how can you get married without experiencing scum, and no one can be a mother casually. You are the only one who has experienced this." Fang Zhiqiang comforted Liu Yan. Liu Yan said this, but she couldn't hold back the tears on her face and burst into laughter.

Nie Qian also laughed, a little helplessly, and asked Fang Zhiqiang: "Are you talking about me?"

Fang Zhiqiang was stunned for a moment, he was just trying to comfort him Liu Yan didn't mean to criticize Sang Huai at all, but unexpectedly, she still let Nie Qian take advantage of her. There really was nothing wrong with him at all. He loved Nie Qian so much at that time and gave so much, but Nie Qian dumped him and followed Qin Xiaojun. How could he not be a scumbag? Even when he hated Nie Qian so much that he gritted his teeth, he wanted to label her as a scumbag.

However, since Nie Qian entered the company, she has completely broken up with Qin Xiaojun, and her abilities in all aspects have gradually been revealed. In fact, she is also a very good girl, but she just made the wrong choice. She herself also suffered the price and understood what kind of person Qin Xiaojun was, and she also completely changed. Although the hatred cannot be eliminated for a while, Fang Zhiqiang will not deliberately think about it anymore. He really didn't mean to disparage Nie Qian this time.

Nie Qian still smiled: "It's okay, I know you didn't mean it. Besides, it was me who did something wrong in the first place. I can't hope to stop everyone from talking. . I was indeed quite a scumbag at that time, so it was retribution. I met Qin Xiaojun, who was considered the best among scumbags. These things are really difficult to explain. One person owes a debt and another person pays it back. There is no way to sort it out. " As she spoke, she poured herself a glass of wine and drank it silently.

Liu Yan was not drunk. Looking at Nie Qian's appearance, she knew that Nie Qian said she was open-minded, but she felt uncomfortable in her heart. She laughed: "Come on, come on, the three of us are in the same boat. We have all fallen in love with scumbags. Let's do it together and drink up all the unhappy people in the past!"

Liu Yan's loss of control and temper could only be seen in front of Bi Luochun. After all, Bi Luochun was the one who hurt her, but in front of Fang Zhiqiang and Nie Qian, she was still a carefree woman.

"This can also be a reason to celebrate." Fang Zhiqiang was speechless, but he knew that this was Liu Yan, who could face the biggest blow with tears and a smile. And he didn't know what to say, so he could only raise the glasses together.

Nie Qian said: "I have to say something. No matter how angry you are, you must listen first.Let me tell you. In fact, I also want to ask the question Lao Bi asked for him, Qiangzi, Yanzi, you can forgive me, why can't you forgive Lao Bi? "

Nie Qian said slowly: "The four of us are actually from the same background, and I have also made mistakes, almost for the same reason as him... People really have mistakes sometimes. He will feel that there is no hope in the life in front of him, and when there are other opportunities, he will not hesitate to seize them and try, even though he may even know that it is wrong from the beginning... I can actually understand him of. He and I may not be like you, we have a very firm idea in our hearts, and we have requirements for ourselves, especially morally. You are both the kind of people who just want to live happily and uprightly, regardless of other people's opinions. It was only after I missed it that I realized that living like this without any psychological burden is really different from before. I once wanted too much and worked too little..."

" Therefore, I think Lao Bi is indeed thinking about you, otherwise he really wouldn't have much need to come back. He treats you much better than I did at that time..." She looked at Fang Zhiqiang, frightened by her fearful attitude towards him and all kinds of suspicion and hurt. There was deep guilt and regret in her eyes, "He I really care about you as a brother. I think he will slowly repent, so why not give him some time and a chance..."

Fang Zhiqiang raised his head and drank a glass of wine, then exhaled: "Nie Qian, I will tell you the truth. Tell me, I believe you can feel it too. In fact, I have not forgiven you, just think that I am a narrow-minded person. No matter how deep my feelings for you were, I was hurt dozens or hundreds of times later. Now I only remember the hurt. What I hope is that I will never have anything to do with you again and treat you as if I have never known each other. Over you. Just because you were desperate at that time and had no other options, I couldn't do it for me to watch you being abused by him to the point of living on the street and not paying attention. This is the minimum bottom line for being a human being and a man. Seeing a weak woman being bullied and not lending a hand to help, I think no one with a conscience can do that. It was Liu Yan's plea to let you work in the company. If she hadn't been so persistent, I wouldn't have agreed. It's just your subsequent behavior that made me change my opinion of you. "

"But Bi Luochun, he is different... His betrayal of me at that time really made things worse, a double blow. After you left, I thought that even if the whole world would betray me, he would not... And his behavior at that time was really difficult for me to accept, it was so disappointing. Besides, now, the forgiveness he is asking for is just for his own peace of mind. What else is there for? Just like Liu Yan said, if Li Xiaoxiao really sued me at that time, what would be my fate now? He doesn’t need my forgiveness at all. He is doing very well now, maybe even much better than me. If I didn’t forgive him, what would it mean to him? How much is my forgiveness worth? ”

Nie Qian fell silent and lowered her head in silence. She didn’t know whether it was because Fang Zhiqiang said that he didn’t forgive her, or because of what Fang Zhiqiang said about his relationship with Bi Luochun. It might be both.

Liu Yan also smiled bitterly and shook her head: "Nie Qian, you don't need to persuade me. If you don't forgive him, it really doesn't mean much. It's only now that I discovered that my understanding of him is even more... I don’t know much about you. You were just confused for a moment, but he went crazy. Qiangzi and I both said that to him. He thought he was not wrong, or in other words, even though he knew he was wrong, he still insists on it. , then how do I forgive him, what do I forgive him for?"